OK, looks like your on 33's...
do you know what your MPG is using the 91 tune on 89 vs 91 octane fuels?
With or without ethenol?
Did you also calibrate the speedo?
No i don't know the difference between 89 versus 91 because it's recommended to use at least 91 octane with the 91 tune. I'm sure you can get away with it. I know what the 91 is tho. Driving normal (strictly city driving in decent traffic) i got 16.255 mpg. I don't know what highway is because i hardly ever do. I'm sure its 21-22.
Just so you all know the performance gains for the different levels are;
91 perf mode 16.93 hp and 20.19 tq
91 tow mode 15.62 hp and 18.61 tq
87 perf mode 10.81 hp and 11.95 tq
There is a 93 tune but SUPERCHIPS never dyno it. According to people they talked to use it see alittle difference or none at all compared to the 91.
Plus 93 octane is not everywhere.